Pay off the mortgage or invest?
This calculator compares three monthly cash-flow scenarios: extra repayments or an offset, investing the spare cash, and an optional debt-recycling illustration. It does not recommend one strategy. Paying down a home loan can create an interest saving at your loan rate that is relatively predictable while the rate remains unchanged. Shares and ETFs can rise or fall; income and capital returns are uncertain, fees and tax matter, and past performance is not a forecast.
What the comparison models
The standard home-loan repayment is calculated as a monthly principal-and-interest annuity over your remaining term. Strategy A pays that repayment plus your spare cash into the home loan. Strategy B pays the standard amount and invests the spare cash. Both reinvest after-tax investment income and invest any monthly budget left after the home loan is repaid. In this model extra repayments and an offset reduce interest in the same way; an offset keeps access to the money, while redraw access and restrictions depend on your loan.
Strategy C is shown only when you select debt recycling. It applies the spare cash to the home loan while it remains outstanding, then redraws that amount into a separate interest-only investment split. The investment loan stays outstanding in the illustration. Interest on money borrowed to buy income-producing investments may be deductible depending on its use, and a redraw is a new borrowing whose purpose matters. Keep investment borrowing separate and traceable. Read the ATO interest-deduction guidance and Taxation Ruling TR 2000/2; ask a tax agent before relying on a deduction. If returns are lower than the investment-loan rate, you can end up worse off.
Tax, dividends and investment growth
The tax input selects the 2026–27 Australian resident marginal rate from the ATO rate schedule, plus the 2% Medicare levy above the lowest threshold in this simplified model. It holds that rate constant over the projection and does not include the Medicare levy low-income reduction, surcharge, deductions, offsets or franking credits. The default 3.3% investment-income yield is based on the S&P/ASX 200 dividend yield of 3.33% at 31 October 2026 in the State Street STW fact sheet, excluding franking. The 4.3% growth assumption reflects Treasury’s average annual capital growth for S&P/ASX 200 10-year holding periods over the past 20 years, described in the Budget 2026–27 tax explainer. Neither figure is a forecast; edit them or use another scenario.
The 2.5% CPI input is the midpoint of the RBA’s 2–3% inflation target. It indexes additions to the investment cost base for the optional sale-tax estimate. The model taxes dividend income monthly at your entered marginal rate and does not estimate dividend franking or other tax outcomes.
The 1 July 2027 capital-gains-tax change
The ATO says the CGT measures are now law, with detail in Treasury’s Budget 2026–27 material and its tax explainer. From 1 July 2027, the 50% CGT discount for individuals, trusts and partnerships is replaced by cost-base indexation and a 30% minimum tax on real capital gains. Assets held before that date keep the 50% discount on the gain accrued up to the change. This calculator applies the new treatment to the whole gain as a simplification; exact CPI quarters and ATO tools are still to come. Income-support recipients such as Age Pension or JobSeeker recipients are exempt from the minimum tax in a year they receive a payment; that exemption is not modelled. The “show tax if I sell” switch only changes this illustrative sale estimate.
Interpreting the outputs
Compare the home-loan balance, portfolio, estimated CGT and net position at your chosen horizon. A rough income-return hurdle is the home-loan rate divided by (1 minus your tax rate): the pre-tax income return needs to be higher to match an after-tax loan-interest saving. That shortcut is not the calculator's full break-even because capital growth is taxed on sale, the cost base is indexed, and the strategies have different balances and timing. The break-even output finds the total pre-tax yield and growth, keeping their ratio, where the investing path matches the extra-repayment path at your horizon. It is a mathematical threshold, not an expected return. The crossover year is the first year-end where the investing path is ahead; if it does not happen within the period, the tool says so. Mortgage-free timing is simulated over the full loan term, not just the comparison horizon.
The optional FIRE number is annual spending multiplied by 25, a simplified 4% rule of thumb. It ignores super access age, the Age Pension and future inflation and is not a retirement plan. Shares and ETFs are assumed; residential property, negative gearing, transaction costs and investment fees are outside this model.
This is general information only — investing involves risk; returns are not guaranteed and past returns are not a forecast. Results are estimates, not a quote, approval, personal tax or financial advice. Test lower-return scenarios and speak with a licensed financial adviser and tax agent before changing your loan or investments.
